First in a series of posts which I basically wrote and finished except for putting them in WordPress or actually, y’know, posting them, and then forgot about as weeks became months. In this first installment, we get something like the NFL-related post I kept meaning to write back when the NFL season was still fresh in our minds.
So, reactionaries continue to flog the notion that public union employees need to be “taken down” because they get more money and better benefits than “the rest of us,” at least per some sort of dubious comparison. Facts and figures don’t seem to come into it really, as per usual; the argument seems to be a purely-emotional one. “They have more and that’s unfair! And your tax dollars are paying for them to have more, too! LET’S GET ‘EM!”
This appeal of this notion, whether logical or emotional, continues meanwhile to elude me entirely. I’m starting to think that I may have underestimated how many people do find something persuasive in this line of attack, though. Not only because the reactionaries keep shouting it, but also because I encountered a surprising variant form of the concept in today’s reader mail for Peter King’s Monday Morning Quarterback.
I’ve been playing cards with the same group of 16 guys once a month for the past three years. [...] I wanted to let you know that not one person was on the side of the players. Not that we were pro owners, we were simply just disgusted with the players. Over the past few years, several of us have been laid off, others have taken reduction in pay. Not once did we demand to see our company’s financials. We simply worked harder, either at our current jobs or finding new jobs, to support our families. I doubt it comes to this, but if things get as bad as they were during the strike, you will find me at Fed Ex field every Sunday cheering the replacement players on the Redskins. And I’m a Cowboys fan.
Okay, on the one hand, NFL players seem like a more legitimate target for envy and resentment than government employee unions; as I’ve noted I can’t really sympathize with the players.
On the other hand: seriously? Are you effing kidding me? (more…)
